Call us at 0117 251 0081
The Difference Between Armed and Unarmed Security Guards
Security is an essential component of safety for businesses, residential areas, and public spaces. When hiring security personnel, one of the key decisions to make is whether to employ armed or unarmed security guards. While both play vital roles in protecting people and property, their responsibilities, training, and risk levels differ significantly. Understanding these differences helps organizations choose the right type of security for their specific needs.
1. Definition and Primary Role
- Armed Security Guards
Armed security guards are licensed professionals who carry firearms while on duty. Their presence serves as both a deterrent to potential criminals and a direct line of defense in situations that could involve weapons or violence. They are often deployed in high-risk environments where the threat level is elevated. - Unarmed Security Guards
Unarmed guards, on the other hand, do not carry firearms. They rely on non-lethal methods such as communication, surveillance, and de-escalation techniques to handle security concerns. Their main focus is to observe, report, and prevent incidents through visibility and vigilance.
2. Training and Licensing Requirements
- Armed Guards:
Armed guards undergo extensive training that includes firearms handling, marksmanship, and legal regulations concerning the use of deadly force. They must obtain specific licenses and pass background checks and psychological evaluations. Ongoing training and recertification are also typically required to ensure they remain competent and compliant with the law. - Unarmed Guards:
While unarmed guards receive professional security training, it usually focuses on areas like conflict resolution, observation skills, emergency response, and customer service. Their training emphasizes prevention and de-escalation rather than force.
3. Work Environments
- Armed Guards:
These guards are commonly employed in high-security locations such as banks, government facilities, jewelry stores, and large corporations handling sensitive or valuable assets. They may also protect high-profile individuals or events with elevated risk levels. - Unarmed Guards:
Unarmed guards typically work in environments where the risk of violence is lower—such as retail stores, residential communities, schools, or office buildings. Their role often combines security with customer assistance and maintaining order.
4. Cost Differences
- Armed Security:
Hiring armed guards generally costs more due to the higher level of training, insurance, and licensing required. Organizations pay for the added expertise and liability coverage associated with the potential use of deadly force. - Unarmed Security:
Unarmed security services are more affordable, making them suitable for businesses or institutions that require a strong security presence without the risks or costs linked to firearms.
5. Risk and Liability
- Armed Guards:
While they provide a stronger defense against violent threats, armed guards also come with higher liability risks. Any misuse of a firearm can have serious legal and reputational consequences for both the guard and their employer. - Unarmed Guards:
Because they do not carry weapons, unarmed guards pose less liability risk. Their approach to managing threats relies on communication, observation, and coordination with law enforcement when necessary.
6. Choosing the Right Type of Security
Selecting between armed and unarmed security guards depends on factors such as the level of threat, type of property, and budget.
- Businesses dealing with high-value assets or sensitive information may benefit from armed protection.
- Facilities prioritizing a welcoming, low-risk environment may find unarmed guards more appropriate.
Conclusion
Both armed and unarmed security guards play critical roles in maintaining safety and order. The main difference lies in their preparedness to confront threats—armed guards are equipped to respond to violent situations, while unarmed guards focus on prevention and de-escalation. The best choice ultimately depends on the specific security needs, potential risks, and desired level of protection for a given location or organization.